Sometimes, food and shelter just aren’t enough.
A bill at Colorado’s Capitol says dogs and cats deserve more when they’re lost or abandoned – they need mental and emotional care, too.
Lawmakers want to ensure that dogs and cats are adopted, returned to their owners or transferred to another shelter.
Senate Bill 164 establishes a standard of care for dogs and cats and says they must receive appropriate food, water, shelter, medical care and enrichment.
“A dog’s or cat’s quality of life and health includes mental and emotional well-being as well as physical health,” SB164 says.
“It’s about caring for our animals … people love their pets,” said Sen. Rhonda Fields, D-Aurora, who is championing the measure.
Colorado lawmakers want to stop dogs, cats from being euthanized
The legislation – which passed the Senate and is heading to the House – would still allow an animal to be euthanized if it is terminally ill, injured or aggressive, but not because of a lack of space or time spent at a shelter.
Colorado’s shelters and rescues are licensed and inspected by the state’s Department of Agriculture, through the Pet Animal Care Facilities Act program.
In 2018, 184,293 animals – everything from goats to snakes – ended up in animal shelters. And about 89% of them were adopted, returned to their owners or transferred to another shelter, according to data collected by the Colorado Department of Agriculture.
“This (bill) wouldn’t have too much impact for us because we are already operating on those standards, and I don’t know many that are not,” said Chris Nelson, director of animal services for the La Plata County Humane Society.
“If the animal is a danger of causing harm or death to an animal or a person, then we will euthanize. Or if they have an illness or disease that’s not curable and they will have a poor quality of life,” Nelson said.
But he said the bill might create challenges for shelters that struggle with overcrowding. He said the La Plata County Humane Society used to euthanize for space, but not anymore.
“We used to euthanize 30% of our dogs and cats before I started. Right now, we euthanize about 2% to 3%, and that’s for health reasons,” Nelson said. “We even hospice out some of our dogs and cats.”
Part of the reason the shelter has been able to decrease euthanasia rates is because of the practice of trap, neuter, release, which is when a shelter collects feral cats, spays or neuters them, then releases them back into the wild. But the practice doesn’t immediately lower population and it doesn’t help get more animals placed in a home. It just helps reduce future populations.
Nelson said they’ve come a long way, and that the dog population in Southwest Colorado is under control. But cats have a “long way to go.”
Colorado lawmakers want to stop dogs, cats from being euthanized
Jennifer Crouse, shelter supervisor for the city of Cortez’s animal shelter, says her facility also used to struggle with overcrowding.
“Since we’ve significantly increased our transports to other shelters in the last few years, our overcrowding has gone way down,” Crouse said. “It’s not really a problem anymore. And our euthanasia has gone down by about 60% as well.”
She says her shelter relies on grant money from the Animal Assistance Foundation to help bolster a small medical budget.
The bill received pushback from a handful of Republican lawmakers, including Sen. Don Coram of Montrose, who worried that it will cause shelter overcrowding.
“In the western part of Colorado, there’s just not as much of a demand for pet adoption,” Coram said, adding that overcrowding is in part because of Colorado shelters accepting so many animals from out of state.
Sen. Bob Gardner, a Colorado Springs Republican who opposed the measure, said it is merely “feel-good legislation.”
“This bill doesn’t create a standard of care. The standard of care already exists,” Gardner said. “It won’t help the pet that was improperly euthanized. If this was a bill that would do that, I wouldn’t be standing up here and saying that this bill doesn’t do anything.”
Gardner criticized the measure for neglecting to protect other critters.
“It does choose dogs and cats over hedgehogs, and as you recall on second reading, I told you that my daughter has a hedgehog. And I don’t think it’s going to escape, but if it did, he would go to the animal shelter. There’s no standard of care in here for the hedgehog,” he said.
Colorado lawmakers want to stop dogs, cats from being euthanized
“The socially conscious animal community movement strives to create the best outcomes for all animals by treating them respectfully and alleviating suffering – two key commitments all veterinarians take upon entering veterinary school,” Katherine Wessels, a spokeswoman for the Colorado Veterinary Medical Association, said in a written statement.
It’s the model used by the Humane Society of the Pikes Peak Region.
“We will never euthanize for time or space,” said Kate Aviv, community relations specialist for the Humane Society of the Pikes Peak Region in Pueblo. “We don’t turn away any animals in need.”
“If we see they’ve been here too long, we will transfer to another place. Or we will transfer them into foster care so they can be in homes while they wait,” Aviv said. “A lot of no-kill shelters can pick and choose which ones they take into the shelters. But socially conscious shelters have to take in every animal.”
If a pet is found, Aviv’s shelter holds it for five to six days and tries to find the owner by posting on lost-and-found boards, checking microchips and scanning Facebook posts.
She says their organization – which includes shelters in Colorado Springs, Pueblo, Centennial and Douglas County – has an extensive network of shelters that work together to house animals with specific needs. But they don’t transfer animals outside of their jurisdiction.
In 2018, 6,199 animals came through the Pueblo location, with 1,603 of them being adopted and 1,312 being reunited with their owners.
About 666 animals were euthanized in the shelter, and another 385 were euthanized at owners’ request. The remainder of the animals were either transferred to other facilities or died of natural causes. Between all four shelters, the organization euthanized about 10% of their animals.
Colorado lawmakers want to stop dogs, cats from being euthanized
Aviv said she’s excited to see legislators discussing how to care for animals in shelters in the most ethical way possible.
“I do believe it’s the best approach to sheltering,” Aviv said.
For Rep. Monica Duran, D-Denver, who is helping bring the bill, it’s about giving animals a second chance. “We need to be caring for our animals,” said Duran, who owns two Pomeranians.
In early February, Duran brought a measure that would have put more regulations on puppy mills, but it did not make it out of committee. She said it failed because small pet stores were worried the changes would cost their businesses too much money.
“With legislation like this, it’s all about changing mindsets,” she said.
The animal shelter bill is also being led by Sen. Joann Ginal, D-Fort Collins, and Rep. Alex Valdez, D-Denver.
If enacted into law, the legislation would take effect in August.
Reader Comments